In AV-TEST’s July and August 2026 Windows 11 evaluation, all 15 home products qualified for its TOP PRODUCT award. Twelve earned 18 out of 18. In a separate online threat test, AV-Comparatives found meaningful differences between some of the same products.
This guide compares seven antivirus options with Microsoft Defender. It shows how each performed against online threats and malicious files, what the performance scores measure, and how to switch safely if you decide to try an alternative.
Do you still need antivirus in 2026?
Windows 11 already includes Microsoft Defender Antivirus. Whether to replace it depends on what you do on your PC and which features you need. Malicious downloads, fake installers and convincing links can all put passwords, browser sessions and personal files at risk.
Dangerous page blocked
This page pretends to be a delivery service and asks for your card details. Your security software stopped it before the page loaded.
A good security product helps in four practical ways:
- It can block known phishing pages and malicious downloads, depending on the product’s web protection and browser settings.
- It can flag suspicious behavior from programs that signature-based scans miss.
- It can help stop ransomware. Recovery features vary by product, so keep a separate backup of important files.
- Some plans alert you to exposed credentials. Check which accounts and regions the service covers.
What the lab tests actually measure
AV-TEST assigns up to six points each for protection, performance and usability. Eighteen is the maximum, and a score of at least 17.5 earns the TOP PRODUCT badge.
AV-TEST, July and August 2026
AV-TEST tested 15 Windows 11 home products at default settings, with updates and cloud services enabled. Twelve scored 18/18, including Bitdefender Total Security, Norton 360, ESET Security Ultimate, Kaspersky Premium, McAfee Total Protection and Avast Free Antivirus. Microsoft Defender, TotalAV and EnigmaSoft SpyHunter scored 17.5. Defender earned 6/6 for protection and 5.5/6 for performance.
AV-Comparatives: three different tests
AV-Comparatives runs separate tests for online threats, file-based malware and system performance. Its protection awards take false alarms into account.
- Real-World Protection Test (July to October 2026). The lab tested 20 products against 400 online threats. Avast One Free, AVG AntiVirus Free and Norton Antivirus Plus blocked all 400 in this round. Microsoft Defender blocked 389.
- Malware Protection Test (September 2026). The lab used 10,000 malicious files. It measured detection and also checked whether products prevented infection when undetected files were run. Defender and McAfee received STANDARD. False alarms contributed to both awards.
- Performance Test (September 2026). Lower impact scores mean less slowdown on the lab’s test PC. McAfee led with 3.1, while Microsoft Defender scored 13.5. Impact scores are benchmark points.
How to read the awards. G DATA blocked 398 of 400 online threats. False alarms lowered its Real-World award, which illustrates why the protection rate and the award can tell different stories.
The labs sometimes test different editions. AV-TEST used Norton 360 and ESET Security Ultimate, while AV-Comparatives used Norton Antivirus Plus and ESET HOME Security Essential in its online protection test. In the September file test, offline detection ranged from 40.2% to 97.3%. Those figures measure detection before execution. The final protection results also account for what happens when an undetected file runs with cloud access available.
The 7 best antivirus picks for Windows
These seven picks cover different priorities, from low system impact to bundled tools. Check the exact edition, device limit and renewal price before buying.
Bitdefender Total Security
Best all-round protectionBitdefender Total Security earned 18/18 at AV-TEST and ADVANCED+ in both AV-Comparatives protection tests. It also earned ADVANCED+ for performance, with an impact score of 8.7.
Bitdefender’s Rescue Environment can scan for persistent threats outside the normal Windows session. Check the subscription details if you plan to use the bundled VPN regularly, as its data allowance depends on the plan.
Norton 360 Deluxe
Best for extras and many devicesNorton 360 Deluxe bundles tools such as a VPN, password manager, cloud backup and parental controls. Check the local plan for device limits, supported platforms and monitoring features.
Norton Antivirus Plus blocked all 400 online threats in AV-Comparatives’ test and scored 4.9 for PC impact. It received ADVANCED in the file-based test, where false alarms also affect the award. AV-TEST separately awarded Norton 360 18/18.
ESET HOME Security
Best for quiet, flexible protectionESET HOME Security Essential earned ADVANCED+ in both AV-Comparatives protection tests. ESET Security Ultimate scored 18/18 at AV-TEST. Check the edition if you need features such as firewall rules or removable-device controls.
ESET earned ADVANCED+ for performance, with an impact score of 9.5 in the September benchmark.
Kaspersky Premium
Top lab scores, with a trust questionOn numbers alone, Kaspersky has one of the best years on this list: a perfect AV-TEST score, ADVANCED+ in both protection tests and the third-lowest PC impact.
In 2024, the U.S. Bureau of Industry and Security prohibited Kaspersky from providing covered cybersecurity products and services in the United States or to U.S. persons. Germany’s BSI issued a separate advisory in 2022 recommending alternatives. Take official guidance and local availability into account when choosing a security provider.
McAfee Total Protection
Lightest on your PC, built for many devicesMcAfee Total Protection had the lowest impact of the 20 products in the September performance test. It also earned ADVANCED+ in the online threat test. Check the local plan for the number of devices it covers.
In the file-based test, McAfee prevented infection in 99.97% of cases and generated 36 false alarms in the separate clean-file test. Its STANDARD award reflects both results.
Avast Free Antivirus
Best free third-party optionAvast Free Antivirus scored 18/18 at AV-TEST. AV-Comparatives tested Avast One Free for online and file-based threats. It blocked all 400 online threats and earned ADVANCED in the file-based test. Avast Free Antivirus scored 5.2 for PC impact. The two Avast editions may differ in features and interface.
AVG AntiVirus Free posted similar results and is another free option if you prefer its interface.
G DATA Total Security
A solid European alternativeG DATA Total Security earned ADVANCED+ in the file-based and performance tests. AV-TEST awarded G DATA Internet Security 17.5/18 and TOP PRODUCT in its May and June round.
The Total Security edition may appeal if you want bundled backup tools. In the July to October online protection test, G DATA blocked 99.5% of threats, with false alarms lowering its award.
Honorable mentions. F-Secure Total and Malwarebytes Premium each scored 18/18 at AV-TEST. Malwarebytes Premium did not qualify for an award in the September file-based test, where false alarms also counted. Its AV-TEST score alone gives an incomplete picture.
Is Microsoft Defender enough?
Microsoft Defender is a reasonable starting point for most home users with an up-to-date Windows 11 PC. Its results were mixed across labs. It earned 17.5/18 at AV-TEST and blocked 389 of 400 online threats in AV-Comparatives’ July to October test.
Virus & threat protection
Protection for your device against threats.
No current threats.
Last scan: today (quick scan)
No action needed.
In AV-Comparatives’ September file-based test, Defender achieved 99.89% online protection and triggered 28 false alarms, earning STANDARD. Its PC impact score of 13.5 was higher than those of the seven alternatives featured here.
Keep Windows and your browser updated, install software from trusted sources and maintain backups. Consider another suite if you want different protection or need features such as a VPN, breach alerts or coverage for several devices. A compatible third-party antivirus normally becomes the active real-time provider.
If you suspect a persistent infection and Defender is your active provider, save your work. Open Windows Security → Virus & threat protection → Scan options → Microsoft Defender Antivirus (offline scan) and choose Scan now. The PC restarts and scans in the Windows Recovery Environment. After it restarts again, check Protection history. Microsoft’s offline scan instructions.
Antivirus comparison table
The table shows AV-TEST scores, AV-Comparatives online protection rates, file-based awards and performance scores. The online protection rate measures the share of cases blocked in that test. Awards also account for false alarms.
| Antivirus | AV-TEST (Jul-Aug 2026) | Online protection (Jul–Oct 2026) | Malware (Sep 2026) | PC impact (Sep 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bitdefender | 18/18 | 99.0% | ADVANCED+ | 8.7 |
| Norton | 18/18 | 100% | ADVANCED | 4.9 |
| ESET | 18/18 | 99.0% | ADVANCED+ | 9.5 |
| Kaspersky | 18/18 | 99.5% | ADVANCED+ | 3.3 |
| McAfee | 18/18 | 99.0% | STANDARD | 3.1 |
| Avast Free / Avast One Free | 18/18 | 100% | ADVANCED | 5.2 |
| G DATA | 17.5/18 (May–Jun) | 99.5% | ADVANCED+ | 8.3 |
| Microsoft Defender | 17.5/18 | 97.3% | STANDARD | 13.5 |
Lower PC impact scores indicate less slowdown in the benchmark. The Avast AV-TEST score is for Avast Free Antivirus. The AV-Comparatives protection tests use Avast One Free. The performance test uses Avast Free Antivirus. The G DATA AV-TEST score is for Internet Security and the AV-Comparatives results are for Total Security.
Which one should you choose?
Bitdefender Total Security, with top results in both protection tests.
Norton 360 Deluxe, if you want a VPN, backup and monitoring in one plan.
McAfee Total Protection had the lowest impact in this benchmark. Avast Free Antivirus and Norton Antivirus Plus also scored well.
Microsoft Defender, or Avast Free if you want a third-party option.
ESET, Bitdefender or G DATA, all based in Europe.
Kaspersky Premium, if you are comfortable with the political questions around it.
Start with Defender if you need basic protection and prefer to use the tools built into Windows. Bitdefender is a strong option if you value consistent protection awards across both AV-Comparatives tests. Consider Norton 360 Deluxe if you also need its bundled tools.
How to try one and switch safely
Every PC is different, so a free trial is the fairest test. Do it in this order to avoid conflicts.
Download the installer from the vendor’s site. Check trial terms and automatic renewal before signing up.
Remove the old third-party antivirus. Go to Settings → Apps → Installed apps, open the menu beside the product and select Uninstall. Restart and confirm the active provider under Windows Security → Virus & threat protection → Manage providers. Microsoft’s guide to checking your provider.
Install the replacement. Restart if prompted, then verify in Windows Security that the new antivirus is the active provider and that it has updated.
Try it during normal use. Check startup, app launches and any false alerts. If you remove it, restart and confirm that Microsoft Defender or your chosen replacement is active.
Check the renewal price. Many plans are cheap in year one and noticeably more expensive after that. Put the trial end date in your calendar so you are not billed by surprise.
Quick checklist before you buy
- Use one active real-time antivirus. Multiple real-time scanners can interfere with each other.
- Buy from the official site. Look-alike shops sell the same product with hidden extras or invalid keys.
- Compare the renewal price, not just the first-year offer.
- Keep Windows, your browser and your apps updated. Updates close the holes that malware uses.
- Turn on two-step sign-in for email, banking and shopping accounts.
- Keep a separate backup. Disconnect external backup drives after use, or use a cloud backup with version history you can restore.
Frequently asked questions
Is Microsoft Defender enough in 2026?
Defender is a reasonable default on an updated Windows 11 PC. It scored 17.5/18 at AV-TEST, blocked 97.3% of online threats in the July to October AV-Comparatives test and earned STANDARD in the September file-based test. A third-party suite can replace it if you need a different balance of protection, performance or features.
Can I run two antivirus programs at the same time?
No. Two real-time scanners can clash with each other and slow the PC down. Use one security suite with real-time protection. A free on-demand scanner for the occasional second opinion is fine, as long as its real-time shield stays off.
Is Kaspersky legal to use in Greece and the EU?
The U.S. restrictions cover U.S. persons and the U.S. market. Germany issued separate cybersecurity guidance recommending alternatives. For current rules and availability in Greece, consult local authorities and check the regional product page.
Does antivirus software slow down my PC?
Yes, the impact depends on the PC and what you do on it. AV-Comparatives measured impact scores from 3.1 to 39.8 on its test system. Compare app launches and everyday tasks during a trial to see how the product affects your own PC.
Do I need antivirus on my phone?
Keep your phone updated, use trusted app stores and be cautious with links. Android security apps may provide app checks and phishing protection. On iPhone, third-party apps are sandboxed, so security apps generally focus on features such as web protection and breach alerts.
💬 Comments